@iris_meredith You are touching on important stuff, but I think there are multiple different forces at work that shouldn't be put under the same umbrella:
"kind of programmer who's only interested in programming and tech in general tends to be a second-rate software developer at best" - What I found is that a large part (possibly majority) of programmers are not even interested in programming and tech. This set probably has a major overlap with those who don't read and generally lack curiosity.
On the other hand I know great programmers who are also quite literate, but hate to write docs and have some of those Really Clever Tricks in their code no one can figure out (incl. their future selves).
There are probably other dimensions and linear sums too.